i have changed my opinion of this identification. i was probably wrong then. sorry that i made confusion like this.
here i have marked the details which make me think that this is not Robert. on the base of the tail there is black colour stretching down over the white, forming a 'comb-like' pattern (yellow ellipses). the centre spots are symmetrical (red ellipse).
in Robert's tail the division of black/dark and white is sharp in the base of the tail. also the centre spot is a little a-symmetrical: the left side is bigger than the right.
now when i tried to look for a suitable picture for comparison i found this and i see that there is not such a sharp division of black and white as i wrote first.
does the black colour stretch lower in the above picture? maybe they are new feathers with less wear than in the lower picture which is taken on Apr 25.
but the centre spot is more asymmetrical than in the above picture. to me the upper bird looks lee robert than the real Robert below.
... this is too difficult. i'm not sure of anything anymore. is it the same eagle or not? i don't even know how stable there patterns in the tail are on adult eagles...
here's another example of Robert on Apr 27:
how about Robert's injury then?
i don't think we have seen a limping eagle on the nest since Feb 22, have we? then he was still clearly limping. an injury like that doesn't heel quite overnight.
edit: i watched the video in your quote, Grieta. this male who got up to the branch did not limp. when did Robert first have the injured foot? i forgot.
and another thing which i forgot: besides transient dirt the tiny dark spots and stripes in the tips of tail feathers may be remnants of the dark edges which young eagles have in their tail before the tail becomes pure white (with the exception of the centre spots).